Press "Enter" to skip to content

Rioting is Wrong

Reason.com

Capitol
The Capitol, Jan. 6, 2021.

 

I cannot say much about the current despicable rioting by Trump supporters at the US Capitol, other than to condemn it and the actions and rhetoric by Trump himself, which have helped inspire it. Rioting is wrong even when done in a just cause, and is especially so when—as here—the cause (bogus claims of election fraud) is pretty obviously unjust.

I would add that I similarly condemned the rioting and looting that occurred this past summer, even though some of those involved did have a just cause (opposing police abuses). Much of what I wrote then is relevant now:

Most of the damage caused by rioting is inflicted on innocent people…. Violence and violation of property rights reduce investment and economic development, which predictably exacerbates the poverty of minority inner-city neighborhoods. The negative economic effects can persist for many years.

It may be tempting to say that rioting and other similar violence is justified if you are doing it in the name of a just cause. But even people with legitimate grievances must still observe moral limits on tactics they use to pursue them. Ignoring this principle is a recipe for disaster.

As I noted in June, one can imagine extreme circumstances where rioting or similar actions are the only way to address some even greater evil. It is plausible to argue that they might be justified in such circumstances. Indeed, a sufficiently extreme situation can justify a wide range of otherwise indefensible actions, including war, suppression of civil liberties, and so on.

Amnon Free Press:  CNN Hosts Claim ‘My Pillow Guy’ Is ‘Filling The Gap’ Of Departed White House Staff

But anyone defending riots on that basis has a high burden of proof to show that the riots really will remedy the evil in question, and that they really are the only way to achieve that objective. That wasn’t true of the riots that occurred this past summer. And the same point applies even more clearly today, when the rioters don’t even have a legitimate grievance to begin with.

Amnon Free Press:  German lockdown: Merkel announces tough new COVID curbs

In the June post, I pointed out that, historically, riots have damaged the cause the rioters and their supporters seek to promote, because they predictably lead to political backlash. As Martin Luther King, Jr. warned in 1968, “riots are socially destructive and self-defeating.” It is quite possible history will repeat itself, and that today’s events will further discredit President Trump and his supporters in the eyes of  majority of Americans.

I am, to put it mildly, no fan of Trump and his many cruel policies, and would be happy to see him take some political damage. But even if today’s violence ends up having some beneficial political effects unintended by the perpetrtors, it is still wrong, and the potential gains are unlikely to be worth the awful cost.

Amnon Free Press:  What Could Happen If an Asteroid Hits Earth

 

As reported by Reason.com. Continue reading this article at Reason.com

All news text, graphics, videos and multimedia content remain the copyrights of the credited original article publisher, in this case - Reason.com

Amnon Free Press is an American conservative news aggregator and publisher with a mission to publish the right news for the right American.

Contact Information: admin (at) amnonfreepress dot com